Don’t Let AI Define What Counts as Good Psychiatry - JAMA ๐Ÿง 

AI can draft formulations, summarize intakes, and do therapy-like exchanges. Patients are also arriving already shaped by chatbots — sometimes helped, sometimes harmed.

An always-agreeable chatbot can feed reassurance-seeking in OCD/health anxiety, or elaborate a delusion until it feels real. ⚠️

The risk isn’t a dramatic AI failure. It’s a quiet thinning of care.

The 15-min med visit was never ideal — it was a compromise built for volume. AI could make that compromise cheaper to scale.

The standard should come from the sickest patients, not the easiest tasks to automate. They need 3 things AI can simulate but not replace:

Formulation as action

Relational work through mistrust, shame, refusal ๐Ÿค

Responsibility — “what I’d recommend if this were me or someone I loved” ❤️

If a chatbot reinforced a delusion, the job isn’t a better fact-check. It’s understanding why that story became compelling, reality-testing without humiliation, and guiding toward treatment.

AI can do some of what psychiatrists do. Will psychiatry keep defining good care by what its most vulnerable patients require?

References:

Taylor et al., JAMA Psychiatry, 2026
https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2026.3454